Showing posts with label Weakland. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Weakland. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 17, 2009

Quote of the day

"In other eras, a disgraced Benedictine monk would disappear into obscure days of prayer and penitential labor; these days he publishes a tribute to homosexuality and anxiously awaits a booking to appear on Charlie Rose and Oprah."

George Neumayr, The Catholic World Report, "Pilgrim's Regress"

Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Former Archbishop Weakland gets to stay among his victims

WISN's Mark Belling and the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel are reporting that former Milwaukee Archbishop Weakland will not be moving to the abbey in New Jersey as he hoped. (Ht: Dad29.)
Weakland said he rescinded his plans to move to St. Mary's Abbey in Morristown, N.J., on May 18 after Abbot Giles Hayes expressed concerns about his presence in the wake of a New York Times story recounting revelations in his forthcoming memoir.

"It seemed evident to me that they thought my presence there might be a negative element for the school and monastery," said Weakland, who discusses his homosexuality and his handling of clergy sex abuse in the book, "A Pilgrim in a Pilgrim Church," which is due out this month.

St. Mary's is home to Delbarton School, a prestigious boys college preparatory school operated by the Benedictine monks of St. Mary's, about 35 miles from Manhattan.

Giles, who is the former headmaster of the school, said Weakland changed his plans without explanation a week earlier, and that he had no reason to believe controversy surrounding the book played a role.

Weakland said that the day he sent the e-mail offering his withdrawal, the Benedictine community was scheduled to meet to discuss concerns about his move.

"I put in the option that I would withdraw if it was a problem," he said.

Weakland, 82, said he would remain in Milwaukee.

As the Lovely Doreen from Waukesha pointed out to me, this means that when Weakland's book does come out he gets to live among the people he wrote about and victimized.

I can well imagine that St. Mary's might have legitimate concerns about having someone who excused and covered-up for pedophiles living close to "a prestigious boys college preparatory school." He certainly would not be considered a positive influence.

Saturday, May 16, 2009

Sounding off on the disgraced Archbishop Rembert Weakland

From today's sound off in the Waukesha Freeman: (ht: Spring City)
Wigderson column

I absolutely loved James Wigderson’s column in Thursday’s Freeman about the disgraced former archbishop of Milwaukee, Rembert Weakland. Right on, Jim! Someone needs to speak up about this man and his poor example to the Catholic community. There are still many confused souls out there because of him. What needs to be done now is to get his name removed from places of honor. My parish, St. William of Waukesha, has a Weakland Room in the Parish Vercelli House. They also often refer to his name when invoking blessings. These things are almost as shocking and scandalous as the things he admits to freely doing while archbishop of Milwaukee. For the purpose of healing, he and his name need to go.

For what it's worth, I would hope they would stop mentioning him once he moves to New Jersey since he will no longer be an archbishop-in-residence (ret.).

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Will Weakland address the real tragedies?

In this week's column for the Waukesha Freeman, I took a look at Archbishop Rembert Weakland's "revelation" (coming soon in book form) that he is a homosexual.
The news broke this week that former Archbishop Rembert Weakland is coming out with a new book in June in which he comes out of the closet to announce that, yes, he is a homosexual. The Associated Press story made newspapers across the country with the breathless revelation, “He’s gay.”

Well, yes. Not too many heterosexuals are blackmailed by a former male paramour in possession of a letter that states the archbishop was in love with him.

Being a homosexual is not a tragedy, at least not in the current era. Assigning pedophile priests to new parishes, covering up the crimes, taking money from the archdiocese to cover up a personal scandal, and acting in defiance of Church authority, all while attendence dwindles and local parishes are forced to close for financial reasons, is hardly the resume of a martyr. Yet Weakland has the temerity to cry about his burdens to an AP reporter to plug his book.

According to the Associated Press, the archbishop writes about the burden of the office, how lonely it is and the lack of feedback and support. One can only hope that somehow in the memoir Weakland finds a little space to apologize for being a burden upon the archdiocese he was expected to lead.

Contrasts with Weakland’s successor are inevitable, and Milwaukee was blessed with Archbishop Timothy Dolan, who seemed anything but burdened by the office. One letter writer to National Review described Dolan’s arrival “as if a great burden was lifted” from the shoulders of the faithful.

Dolan’s demeanor and good cheer while teaching the orthodoxy that so vexed Weakland reminds us of another Irishman, Ronald Reagan. Reagan, too, followed a man who was overwhelmed by the burdens of his office and, like Dolan, relished the office and the opportunity to serve. Perhaps it was the clarity of purpose that buoyed both of them in the difficulties they faced.

That moral clarity eluded Weakland in both his personal and professional life. That is the tragedy of Archbishop Weakland, not his sexual orientation, and it will take a better man than him to write about it.

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Top ten revelations in Archbishop Rembert Weakland’s new book

With apologies to David Letterman

10) Difficult to find a date to see “Phantom of the Opera” when you’re an archbishop
9) Really wished the Village People would play more church festivals
8) Thought the name should have been changed on the Cousins Center to Weakland’s Weekend Love Shack
7) Can’t understand why that Dolan guy got to be Archbishop of New York when he’s not even from there.
6) The money taken from the archdiocese used to pay hush money to Paul Marcoux was paid back with Weakland’s bingo winnings.
5) Thought he was taking an oath to eat all of his celery, not an oath of celibacy.
4) Closed some churches, rebuilt his cathedral, just like Henry VIII on “The Tudors.”
3) Can’t understand why everyone misses that Dolan guy.
2) Original title, “I’m smarter than the Pope.”

And the number 1 revelation in Archbishop Weakland's new book:
1) He’s really gay. No, really.

Monday, February 23, 2009

Dolan heading to the Big Apple

Archbishop Dolan was easily forgiven when he jokingly claimed resistance to the idea of moving to Milwaukee. “Oh Lord, not me. I don't know how to drive in the snow.” But other factors might have caused him to pause when the call came with his appointment to Milwaukee. Dolan’s successor may pause at his appointment, too, as Dolan will be a tough act to follow.

It is now easy to forget the demoralized and dispirited nature of the local Catholic faithful after so much scandal under Dolan’s predecessor, Archbishop Rembert Weakland. Bad enough Weakland represented the weak theology of the Church’s leftwing, but he piled on a personal scandal on top of the already damaging scandal of priestly sexual abuse. When it was revealed that Weakland helped cover up much of the sexual abuse and shielded the guilty, and then had his own sexual scandal, many in the pews were left to wonder what kind of institution to which they belonged. The damage continues from that awful era, as the Archdiocese continues to try to make restitution to the victims and, as Milwaukee Magazine reported, fundraising continues to lag.

Dolan’s orthodoxy was contrary to the desires of many of the priests in the archdiocese. Many actively resisted, and even issued a letter calling for an end to priestly celibacy.

At the same time, some would have preferred a stronger reaction from Dolan. But while Dolan did not deny Communion to wayward politicians or restore the Cathedral to it’s pre-renovation state, Dolan’s eloquent persistence in teaching the traditional church doctrine was a welcome change over his predecessor.

Dolan’s ability to reach out into the community, his large presence and character, will be terribly missed by the entire community, not just Catholics. His ebullient nature may not have healed all rifts but it restored the sagging spirits of a flock in need.

Such is the nature of New York’s gain and our loss that it’s hard not to be selfish at a time like this. Our prayers go with the Archbishop to his new assignment, although some wit will no doubt observe, “First Sabathia, then Favre, now Dolan? How much more do we have to give to New York?”

Tuesday, May 20, 2008

Would you trust your kid to David Prosser?

Does it occur to Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice David Prosser that his version of the story doesn't sound so great, either?
In a December 1978 letter, Wycislo wrote to the chair of the Diocesan Personnel Committee chairman:

"I have just spent a half hour with the district attorney for Outagamie County, who presented me with evidence of a number of crimes of like sexual nature and a number of other civil violations of law that the attorney feels are base enough for a court case against Father (John Patrick) Feeney.

"As is usual in such cases and out of respect for the position of the church, and in order to prevent unnecessary scandal, the DA came to see me merely to state that he was pursuing this case, gathering evidence toward prosecution of Father Feeney for a number of misdemeanors.

"I had to agree with the district attorney that the church would prefer to keep this out of court and out of the public eye and IU was able to tell him of our decision last week, with which he agreed."

Feeney, now 81, was convicted in 2004 and is serving 15 years in jail for assaulting Todd and Troy Merryfield. The incident and its aftermath is the basis for the civil fraud suit that prompted the release of church documents.

Prosser said it was after two reports of Feeney's misconduct that he went to talk to Wycislo in June or July 1978 to suggest Feeney be removed from the public ministry.

Prosser said one set of allegations came from Sharon Merryfield, whom he knew from high school. She said Feeney touched the two sons' chests while they were saying prayers at home before going to bed. Feeney tried to move his hands lower, but one rolled over and the other protested, the woman told Prosser.

Prosser said he believed the boys, but didn't think he could win a case.

"I told Sharon (Merryfield) that a trial was going to be a test of credibility of two young boys against a priest," Prosser said. "I believed the boys. Their credibility would be attacked in court. They would be national news. It would be difficult for them at trial and in their small community."

Prosser noted another factor in his decision was that the state's sexual assault laws were rewritten in the late 1970s — changing from rape to sexual assault — and were complicated and untested.

Prosser said when his he raised concerns about Feeney's conduct, Wycislo said he would "take care of it."

"I assumed that when the Bishop said he would take care of it that he would remove this guy from the parish," Prosser said. "I don't think he acted promptly."

Prosser stopped short of saying the information in the letter was wrong, but said the timeline of the letter's facts is questionable and the bishop's assertions are exaggerated.

Prosser said that in December 1978 he was two weeks away from leaving the prosecutor job to take office in the Wisconsin legislature.

"I did not talk about this with my successor," Prosser said. "I thought it had been over for months."

While not on the level of collusion between Milwaukee District Attorney McCann and Archbishop Rembert Weakland, certainly Prosser had a responsibility to follow up on this case, to examine if there were any more allegations regarding the priest, and to make sure this priest never was allowed near children again. He claims he believed the children. Then he owed them more than just talking to the parish. If not as a prosecutor, then as a human being.